Thanks Jeff. Those Don Ivoino paddle tails look like an exact match. I have some of those Berkley Devil Spears and they are easily twice as thick, so not nearly the finesse presentation I was using. I am saving those links tho.
These are the ones I grabbed on ebay. They do look a little lighter, but I'll give them a try. 4" BEAVER TAIL 28 pk WATERMELON SEED FISH ON LURES - PRO CURE ENHANCED-SCENTED