Jed#1 wrote:Budget is negotiable, but no waders yet. Is familiar with fins from snorkeling and diving. He's pretty skinny
Well Jed, I'm not sure where you're located but even in sunny Southern California we need waders during the winter. lol it's something to consider. An ill child is a big worry for a parent.
As for the tube, I'd suggest getting a V shaped or a pontoon style float tube with two cylindrical bladders. These two types have the least amount of resistance against the water thus making for an easier kick and time on the water.
I've own(ed) 3 tubes and they were the Trout Unlimited Bighorn, ODC 420, and the Cumberland. If I had to pick a best tube I'd go with the Cumberland simply because it works the best right out of the box without requiring any kind of mods unless you're foolish like me and SOMEHOW manage to lose the stripping apron. lol
The Cumberland also sits the person high out of the water, is light, and has little to no drag when kicking even though it is on the heavier side.
As for the other two I've own(ed) the Bighorn I disliked the most simply because the bladders were weak and unreliable. The valve is a joke and took a hell of time to inflate. But, it did have a ton of storage space, the most out of all 3 tubes in fact.
Finally, the ODC 420, this tube is a tank. The hull is strong, the bladders are great and strong as well. And, the design overall is just bulletproof. My only complaints about this one was the fact that you have to readust the valve while inflating until it sits perfectly in the pockets. Also, the seat is made of 2 foam blocks rather that one so you get this thing called the taco effect. I hated that. My back was sore at the end of my trips. I had a fix on that. Go check out my post on the fix. Finally, the storage space was poorly designed in that it had too many small pockets rather than a few simple big ones.
I hope this helps.