It's definitely a calculated risk. One I wouldn't take in say newport, but at cherry beach I've only ever run into 1 seal. I think it all depends on your location. But I also firmly believe in following ones own inner monologue. Gar dont bother me for example, but I'd never put my delicate self into water that might hold alligator snapping turtles lol!
I’ve never been bothered personally by gar, but I’ve had them attack fish I’m trying to land. Like barracuda, it’s the accidental incident you have to watch out for with them.
A large turtle came and bit my fin once, but that’s it.
I’m certain both will wreak havoc on a fabric mesh bag.
I’m thinking one of those metal mesh ones, with a large noodle ring for flotation might do the trick